1. **ATTENTION ALL DEVILS** If you are still having trouble logging in, (Resetting your password should do "the trick") Optimum Online is blocking JD emails for some reason*, OR if you are not technically capable of doing this; use the "Contact Us" form utilizing your current, valid email address. If your email address is 'lost' to you, simply providing some account details will get us on the correct path together. THERE IS NO NEED TO CREATE SECONDARY ACCOUNTS, STOP BEING SO LAZY! YOU WILL BE BANNED! (Yelling/impolite voice implied there for *maximum effect*)
    Dismiss Notice

what should i get for a side opening automatic

vdefino Feb 24, 2016

  1. fastr19

    fastr19 Brigade Member Brigade Member

    301
    111
    53
    Yes.
     
  2. vdefino

    vdefino Average member

    79
    1
    0
    What I mean is yes I know that but some of the benchmade autos on review received 3 stars for some for 200+ items. The H&K had no less then 4 star review from last time I saw. That's what I mean by overlooking benchmade autos. I actually saw a review for blade wiggle on Pirahnas so they are out. Too bad they had a nice price tag
     
  3. stdlrf11

    stdlrf11 A Most Impressive Member Super Moderator Brigade Member

    12,291
    4,324
    113
    I'm probably going to pick up an Emerson Launch soon. I'm pretty drawn too it.
     
  4. Brian_W204

    Brian_W204 Enormous member

    732
    385
    73
    When reading reviews, make sure to ask yourself if the sample is statistically significant. If there are only a handful of reviews, the answer is no. If not, read the individual reviews and see if their pros and cons apply to you.

    Don't even hesitate to buy Benchmade. The AFO, Pardue, Reflex, and Stryker have been in their model line for nearly 20 years only recently getting minor changes. The only model I really wouldn't recommend is the 5400 Serum, due to the behavior self-preserving internal safety.

    The HK is made by Benchmade and shares it's hardware (screws pivot, button, etc. with their knives). It just uses a little cheaper steel and isn't subject to Benchmade's MAP pricing policy. The HK MP5 auto is a much better knife for around $140, BTW.

    Piranha side openers all seem to all have a little blade play. I'm a bit put off by that, too. I'm convinced it's a fact of life with the hidden pivot, but they're not garbage by any means. I doubt you'd be disappointed if you were using it for house and office use.
     
  5. zogglet

    zogglet Better than Nutella Administrator Lady Devil JDBA Official Member

    2,548
    894
    123
    Let us know how it is; I've been somewhat curious about the Launch functionally, but I'll admit, I'm personally not too into the look of it, specifically the groove design on the handle. However, given the price, if it's a good knife, that outweighs nitpicks about the look in my book, especially when it comes to a good EDC auto, heh.
    :manganr:
     
  6. falcon125

    falcon125 the express train to mayhem Brigade Member

    5,424
    1,168
    123
    I am a big fan of Protech. But I just bought this Kershaw Launch 5 Emerson. (Because this thread got me jonesing a carry piece auto)
    First impression, Solid knife feels good in the hand. Light weight handle heavy blade. A little slow to open if you are used to a Protech but still snappy. Sharp as fuck. No blade play.
    Needed 2 drops of oil out of the box, 1 on button, one on pivot. Its getting snappier as I play with it.

    Bang for the buck- Great. Now I just need to put it through the paces.

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    Oh Ya a big shout out to BladeHQ. They always make me happy.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 31, 2016
    stdlrf11 and SlightChance like this.
  7. zogglet

    zogglet Better than Nutella Administrator Lady Devil JDBA Official Member

    2,548
    894
    123
    Thanks for the info. Sounds like an outstanding value. I'm very used to Protech-level snappiness myself, having four of them, but there's no arguing the bang for the buck here, regardless of my visual nitpicks. Good stuff. Congrats on the buy! :thumbsup:

    (BHQ always makes me happy too, hah.)
     
  8. Sharpazzhell

    Sharpazzhell locomotive disaster

    897
    216
    53
    I used to have protech strider tr3 auto. It is nice spring action. Sharp. And lock up is solid on all protech. Its small size but the ergonomics are great. Some of the other ptotechs have weird handles and it didnt feel comfortable in hand. Cant go wrong with tr3 strider. There in the 200$ range to. Protech is a good company. Also microtech LUDT are serial numbered and they are good too. Yes a hawk deadlock I would go for but theres not too many. If you have a hawk then I don't see any problem with probably the best out the front knife I've seen that's double retraction is the AKC F16. The way it feels in hand is nice and it's fun to play with without misfire. I go with a hawk for d/retraction and single would be a halo. But as far as piranhas go they have great designs but they have side wiggle. Like I said protech you CANT GO WRONG. It's my OPINION about the handle. Protech for cutting and collecting and microtech LUDT ir sacoom elite. I'd skip the ultratech and go for the hawk. Even burn knives have a tiny play but nothing beats the hawk otf. The dalton is in there too. Like someone said preference. Buy what you like and what's in your heart. Ask yourself what you want in it. Ask advice. Even if you have a conflict between 2 protects or a microtech just ASK. Yea I know he baught something and I'm late posting.
     
  9. crogers

    crogers Magnus advocatus diaboli Super Moderator Brigade Member

    39,750
    74,530
    123

    DeadThread6.jpg
     
    Samb, seandavid55 and Scott Meers like this.
  10. KoFred

    KoFred Little Member

    38
    194
    33
    I got 2 protechs this year. Absolutely love them, and can’t wait to get another (they are actually pretty cheap).

    I hate to be that guy since everyone else already said theirs were very sharp out of the box, but mine were not. It’s not a big deal, I can sharpen them if I want, but I was surprised. Got a tr3 operator edition that had an ok edge, and a Newport with basically no edge at all. Anyone else experience that?
     
    snache likes this.
  11. Top Dog

    Top Dog Little Member

    55
    103
    33
    I am a newbie on this forum but I would prefer the Micro-Tech LUDT but that is my preference.

    In comparison to about 20-30 years ago,the auto knives out there are superb.

    Top Dog
     
    Rio likes this.
  12. Rio

    Rio Como un angel JDBA Official Member Knife Maker or Craftsman Brigade Member

    8,309
    2,777
    123
    So far I must been lucky ,all fucking knives cut me pretty well after I take them out of the box, never got one not sharp but if I did I would send that shit back that is liked ordering a whore with no tits and a staple pussy.
     
    snache likes this.
  13. Top Dog

    Top Dog Little Member

    55
    103
    33
    Another good company that makes auto knives is Rat Worx. They are chain driven and during one test,one Rat Worx knife was opened and closed close to 400,000 times. before failing. Repair was only a little oil and good to go.

    Top Dog
     
  14. Sharpazzhell

    Sharpazzhell locomotive disaster

    897
    216
    53
    Yes I remember having a protech flyfather. It's saids careful Sharp but it had edge but it wasn't as sharp as I wanted.
     
  15. snache

    snache Should be a custom title here

    3,279
    8,886
    123
    Definitely, I handle a lot of knives so the odds are good that it will happen.
     
  16. Top Dog

    Top Dog Little Member

    55
    103
    33
    Snatche,
    I would guess if you handle enough knives you will experience some that are sharp and others not so sharp,maybe not sharp at all.
    Could be two from the same batch that may be totally different.

    Many years ago,I saw an ad,I think it was in Field & Stream Magazine for a Wolf Killer Stiletto knife for $9.95 (plus $4.00 shipping) So I sent in my hard earned lawn mower money for that prize piece.

    In due time,it arrived and was good for three maybe four openings & closings. Obviously it was total trash. Wolf Killer? The only thing it killed was my money.

    It was true back then as it is now,you pay for cheap two or more times.

    I would say that most of the quality knife makers listed here produce very good knives.

    Top Dog
     
    snache likes this.
  17. snache

    snache Should be a custom title here

    3,279
    8,886
    123
    Snatche, hahaha, I can be when it comes to food. Agree, Cold Steel, Spyderco, and Benchmade have been pretty consistent with it. The problem is that some of these wonder steels can be quite difficult to sharpen compared to the older/cheaper steels.
     
  18. Brian_W204

    Brian_W204 Enormous member

    732
    385
    73
    I own several dozen Pro-Tech knives and I've had 2 that came with poor edges. One was a Brend 2 and the other a TR-3. In both cases, the edges were not ground completely for about 1/4" up to the tip. Both were well over 10 years ago, too.
     

Share This Page